GSI Forum: General discussion » Package management for non-system locations

Home » Scientific Computing » General discussion » Package management for non-system locations

Show: Today's Messages :: Polls :: Message Navigator

Package management for non-system locations [message #2241]

Tue, 16 August 2005 19:09

Christopher Huhn
Messages: 88
Registered: December 2003
Location: GSI Darmstadt

continuous participant
super-utilisateur

From: lxdv17.gsi.de

Simon Lang, who coordinates the Hades software in /misc/hadessoftware, rose the issue of using a package management system for the software management.

After thinking about it for a while, I realized this problem might be tackled on a larger scale as it fits more use cases i.e. to clean up the software installation mess in /usr/local. Evil or Very Mad

I do not have any good solution yet, but these may be requirements for a package management system that installs to non-system locations:

Package installation shall be possible with normal user privileges
All parts of a software package must be installed below a single directory tree. No files should require to be installed in (/usr)/bin, /etc, /var or the like
Multiple versions of the same software shall be installed in different trees at the same time without interference/conflicts
The package database should also reside below this directory
Features as known from normal package managers should be available:
- List package contents
- List to which package a specific file belongs
- Tell if a file has been modified since installation
- Obey defined package dependencies
Maybe wishlist: allow interdependencies between different installation trees (maybe troublesome, but at least explicit)

My ideas on this matter by now are:

Maybe there exists a solution (at another HEP institute)?
Maybe dpkg can be modified to run no-root-privileges chroot or the like?
Tackle this problem with a version control system and make heavy use of tagging and trunking? This may solve at least some issues.
Maybe I install software you (we?) package into system locations instead? This is done by us anyhow, but multiple parallel versions of stuff are generally troublesome.

Did I forget something important?

What do you think?

Report message to a moderator

Re: Package management for non-system locations [message #2242 is a reply to message #2241]

Wed, 17 August 2005 11:11

Christopher Huhn
Messages: 88
Registered: December 2003
Location: GSI Darmstadt

continuous participant
super-utilisateur

From: lxdv17.gsi.de

Just two potentially interessting links:

http://klik.atekon.de/ - Point'n'click installer for Knoppix
http://smartpm.org/ - Unified package manager for different formats

Report message to a moderator

Re: Package management for non-system locations [message #2243 is a reply to message #2241]

Wed, 17 August 2005 13:21

Christopher Huhn
Messages: 88
Registered: December 2003
Location: GSI Darmstadt

continuous participant
super-utilisateur

From: lxdv17.gsi.de

Håkan Johansson wrote on 17.08.2005 12:31 (by email)

Hello,

I never thought of that, but it could be useful since it somehow would formalise the build process.

Two problems would be that if one want it on an odd kind of machine, one would need to have the package handling environemnt for that. One example is a small axis box we tested (borrowed from hades). Basically a small computer with serial and ethernet
interface, usually with some other custom I/O also. This comes with it's own cross-built environment and is not compatible with any other known distribution.
The other thing is that one gets another step inbetween source and running executables.

The problems above are however more important for hardware related stuff.
For pure software (which also is used by more people), and that usually would run on a standard machine, it makes definately sense to be able to install locally managed packages and by the user.

I'v not tried, but what does dpkg --root=... --admindir=... --instdir=... do for us?

I suppose I should have put this into the forum instead. Feel free.

Report message to a moderator

Previous Topic:

Number crunching on the graphics card

Goto Forum:

-=] Back to Top [=-

[ Syndicate this forum (XML) ] [

] [

]

Current Time: Mon Sep 16 17:50:04 CEST 2024

Total time taken to generate the page: 0.00736 seconds